Private hospitals have been the subject of scrutiny in recent years, with concerns over exorbitant charges and unethical practices. This article explores the reasons behind the high costs associated with private hospitals, how they earn revenue, and the impact on patients. It also sheds light on the role of health insurance and the findings regarding the practices of some major private hospitals. Let's delve into the complex world of private healthcare and the issues surrounding it.
Private Hospitals: Profit-Oriented Business Models:
Private hospitals operate with a profit-driven mindset, often mirroring upscale hotels rather than traditional medical facilities. They set high bed rates, restrict the use of external medicines and diagnostic tests, and inflate costs significantly compared to external providers. This business approach has transformed doctors into salesmen and hospitals into commercial establishments.
Overcharging and Exploitation:
Instances of overcharging in private hospitals have come to light, with patients experiencing inflated bills that sometimes amount to significant sums. Shocking stories have emerged, revealing unjustified price hikes on medications and other medical supplies. Financial considerations often overshadow patient care and well-being.
The Healthcare Affordability Crisis:
In a country where a significant percentage of the population lives below the poverty line, the expensive nature of private hospitals exacerbates the healthcare affordability crisis. A growing number of people struggle to afford medical treatment, with many unable to access necessary healthcare services. Disturbingly, financial burdens have led to cases of individuals resorting to extreme measures to cope with medical expenses.
The Reality of Health Insurance:
Health insurance plays a role in supporting individuals seeking medical treatment. However, many people lack awareness of health insurance options or struggle to understand policy guidelines. Financial constraints prevent some from availing insurance coverage. Patients in India bear a substantial portion of the treatment cost, creating immense stress for families facing critical health conditions.
Private vs. Government Hospitals:
Although government hospitals are available, private hospitals dominate the healthcare landscape. Despite the existence of public healthcare facilities, a significant portion of the population opts for private hospitals, highlighting the perceived advantages and trust in these establishments.
CCI's Investigation into Private Hospitals:
Investigations into healthcare practices have revealed concerning findings regarding certain private hospitals. The investigation sought to understand pricing practices and their impact on patients. The hospitals were found to engage in practices that resulted in higher costs for patients, including inflated prices for room rent, medicine, medical tests, medical devices, and consumables. This sheds light on the financial aspects of private hospitals, which continue to grow at an astonishing rate.
The Competition Commission of India (CCI) conducted an investigation into several prominent private hospitals. In a case study, a syringe was found to cost more in a private hospital than at a chemist shop. This prompted the CCI to research and investigate 12 major hospitals, resulting in startling revelations. The hospitals were found guilty of overcharging and applying unfair pricing practices for room rent, medicine, medical tests, medical devices, and consumables, often charging 2-3 times the reasonable rates. Penalties of 10% were imposed on the hospitals for their wrongdoing. This highlights the increasing wealth and revenue of private hospitals, which continue to grow at an astonishing rate.
The Medicine Markup Game:
Private hospitals and companies have found ways to bypass government regulations on maximum retail prices (MRP) for medicines, resulting in significant price disparities. These frequent revisions of MRP have created a financial burden on patients.
Doctor-Driven Profit Motives:
In corporate hospitals, doctors are often hired on lucrative packages and given targets to achieve, which may include unnecessary tests and surgeries. This profit-oriented approach can lead to situations where patients undergo unnecessary medical procedures. Such practices raise questions about the ethical standards and patient-focused approach of private hospitals.
Marketing Tactics and False Promises:
Private hospitals often resort to aggressive marketing tactics, offering various incentives such as referrals, free ambulance services, and discounts. These strategies can mislead patients into believing they are receiving better care or exclusive benefits. However, it is important to remember that quality healthcare cannot be solely determined by brand promotions or marketing gimmicks.
Seeking Alternatives:
To navigate the expensive healthcare landscape, it is worth considering alternatives beyond large corporate hospitals. Small-sized general hospitals and clinics can provide quality care at more affordable rates without compromising on patient well-being. Understanding the variation in costs within the same hospital, questioning service charges, medicine costs, and doctor fees solely based on room upgrades can help individuals make informed decisions about their healthcare options.
Transforming the System:
It is essential for doctors to play a crucial role in advocating for change within the healthcare system. By actively addressing the issues of overcharging, unnecessary procedures, and unethical practices, doctors can contribute to a more patient-centered approach. Collaboration between doctors, patient advocacy groups, and regulatory bodies is vital to ensure fair pricing, transparent billing practices, and ethical standards in private hospitals.
The high costs associated with private hospitals have raised concerns about the affordability and fairness of healthcare services. Instances of overcharging and unfair pricing practices have been uncovered, shedding light on the challenges faced by patients. The financial burden placed on individuals, coupled with profit-driven business models, creates a complex healthcare landscape. It is crucial for individuals to be aware of their rights, explore alternative healthcare options, and actively engage in advocating for a more patient-centered and transparent healthcare system. By working together, we can strive for affordable, accessible, and ethical healthcare for all.
Why are private hospitals in India so expensive?
Hospitals in India vary in terms of cost and facilities based on their ownership and type. Having worked in various types of hospitals, including government, charitable trust, and corporate hospitals where celebrities and prominent individuals seek treatment, I have observed significant differences in the cost of healthcare services.
Government hospitals in India offer medical services at minimal costs, often serving patients from all walks of life, including those who are economically disadvantaged. While the quality of care provided in government medical colleges is comparable or even superior, patients are typically accommodated in general non-AC wards that tend to be crowded. Due to the high patient load, there is a possibility of delayed tests and treatment, and instances of negligence may occur. The hospital staff, including nurses, ward boys, and doctors, are often overburdened and may exhibit impatience when attending to patient requests.
On the other hand, corporate hospitals cater to a clientele that includes high-class society members, celebrities, and influential individuals. These hospitals prioritize providing a luxurious and comfortable experience akin to a five-star hotel. From the moment a patient's car or ambulance arrives at the hospital, they are greeted by attentive staff members who assist them throughout their visit. The patient service department ensures that patients receive personalized attention and guidance. As these high-class patients expect impeccable service, hospitals strive to maintain their reputation and avoid any negative experiences or legal issues. However, it is important to note that hospitals are committed to treating all patients equally, irrespective of their social status. These premium facilities and services come at a higher cost, as the hospital needs to meet the demands and expectations of their affluent clientele.
In government hospitals, procedures like pleural tapping, which involves draining fluid from the lungs, are often performed by intern MBBS students who gain expertise through regular practice. Conversely, in corporate hospitals, such procedures are conducted under the guidance of interventional radiologists using ultrasound guidance. Interventional radiology is a super-specialty field that requires extensive training and expertise, which is reflected in the higher charges associated with such procedures.
Similarly, in government hospitals, common conditions like acidity are typically treated with commonly prescribed medicines by the resident doctors, while corporate hospitals have gastroenterologists who thoroughly examine the patient and provide specialized treatment. In cases of diabetes, government hospitals may manage the condition with the assistance of medicine residents, whereas corporate hospitals often refer patients to endocrinologists who specialize in managing diabetes and related complications.
The disparity in costs between different types of hospitals is primarily attributed to the high-end services and specialized care provided by corporate hospitals. However, it is important to recognize that the salaries of staff and doctors are consistent across all types of hospitals. In fact, prestigious hospitals may pay higher salaries to attract skilled professionals, as working in such establishments enhances their professional profiles.
Furthermore, corporate hospitals have additional expenses related to providing hospitality services to patients and their families. While everyone acknowledges the high cost of healthcare, it is also expected that hospitals offer a level of hospitality akin to a five-star experience. Patients and their families may become displeased if there are significant waiting times to see doctors, further emphasizing the importance of providing prompt and attentive care.
One of the challenges faced by relatives of patients in government hospitals is the need to navigate various departments for tests, which often involves long queues in the pharmacy. In corporate hospitals, the patient's treatment and care are handled by the hospital staff, allowing relatives to focus on other responsibilities. However, corporate hospitals may present families with a substantial bill upon the patient's discharge, even if the treatment was successful.
While there are valid concerns about the high cost of healthcare, it is essential to understand that private hospitals in India offer a different level of service and comfort compared to government hospitals. Each type of hospital serves a specific purpose and caters to a different patient demographic. It is crucial for patients to make informed decisions based on their healthcare needs, financial capabilities, and expectations.
Here is a sentiment analysis (What people think about it):
"One more incident happened with my grandmother. She wasn’t well and we took her to our family doctor. He examined her and referred her to another hospital. The hospital said that she has a blockage in her heart and needs immediate operation. I looked at my grandmother, and she said that she doesn’t want to get admitted. I took her home. It’s a long time now. She was 72 at that time and now she is 80 and still happily living with us": Positive sentiment. The person expresses happiness and gratitude that their grandmother is still alive and well despite not undergoing the recommended operation.
"My father was diagnosed with chest fungal infection after getting operated for spinal injuries in a well-renowned hospital in Delhi that specializes in spinal treatments. While treating the fungal infection, the hospital charged us 15,000 for an injection per day for 15 days. When we checked the actual cost of the injection outside the hospital, it was only Rs 2,800. Sad but true!":
Negative sentiment. The person expresses disappointment and frustration over the high cost of treatment and the apparent overcharging by the hospital.
"That charge by the hospital, not by doctors. Doctors only employees there. All policies are made by businessmen. Doctors don't earn, hospitals earn. You should have checked the price outside before buying from the hospital. Doctors are on a monthly payment, not in business.":
Mixed sentiment. While some comments imply negative sentiments toward hospitals and businessmen, others defend the doctors and suggest that they are not responsible for the high charges.
"The corruption starts from the huge capitation fee charged by Private Medical Colleges during MBBS admission followed by the exorbitant annual fees. Remember, 21 lakh students appear in NEET for 91,000 seats (government + private).": Negative sentiment. The comment highlights the corruption and high fees in private medical colleges, implying a negative view of the healthcare system.
"I'm very sad as a Govt Medical Doctor that these things are happening in Corporate Hospitals. Corporate or Private Hospitals should be run by the Doctors, not by Management fellows, or else there won't be much Compassion and Honesty.":
Negative sentiment. The person expresses sadness and disappointment regarding the functioning of corporate hospitals and advocates for doctors to be in charge to ensure compassion and honesty.
"I don't believe you. Supplement your claims with evidence. Name and shame the doctor with his address and qualification.":
Negative sentiment. The person expresses doubt and demands evidence for the claims made in the video.
"As I am a staff nurse... I am agree with you... I have seen everything. Even there are so many poor patients... but they care":
Mixed sentiment. The person agrees with the claims made in the video and expresses empathy for the plight of poor patients.
"We are with you, sir this type of fact must be disclosed to the general public. The government should definitely take legal action.": Positive sentiment
More Sentiments:
Positive Sentiments:
Very informative video... hospital scam must stop... Gov of India should take action.
We need good doctors, especially from rural areas. This work is done by Sri Sathya Sai Sanjeevani hospitals all over India.
Negative Sentiments:
I have 3 years of experience in the hospital field, and what you have said is 100% true. Sad truth.
Ventilator scam happened to us in one of the renowned hospitals in Pune. My cousin's grandmother was sick.
My mother had thyroid cancer, and my local doctor suggested a private hospital instead of Red Cross hospital.
An injection worth Rs 300 was charged at Rs 4800 in the private hospital. The lab tests are charged at 10 times normal rates.
In private hospitals, they always do caesarean delivery only for more money.
Yes, my mom was in Jupiter Hospital Thane, and later was admitted to Horizon Hospital, and the same disaster happened.
Neutral Sentiments:
For delivery, I heavily recommend Kamladevi Memorial Hospital in Pune. Dr. Sachin Rao is a gem of a person.
There is a huge gap in the market for hospitals that treat patients humanely and do not try to use their hapless situation to extract as much money as possible out of them.
It's simple: a private hospital sees a patient as a customer.
There is no control on private hospitals.
Someone sensible raising the right issue, just need to tell you that it's a corporate which is playing both with doctors as well as patients.
Doctors Sentiment:
Confounding bias: The article may suffer from a confounding bias because it focuses on the financial aspects of hospitals without considering the reality of patient demands or the differentiation between doctors and management.
Sensationalizing the topic: There should be an attempt to sensationalize the topic rather than offering constructive advice.
Responsibility of the article creator: The content may lead patients to blame and abuse doctors for higher prices, which can be unfair and unjustified.
Price variation in other industries: The article points out that price variation exists in other industries, such as different outlets selling the same product at different prices. They argue that blaming only the healthcare industry, doctors, and hospitals is unfair, and other manufacturers and the government should also be held accountable.
Government control and regulation: The article agrees that the government should have control over pricing practices in healthcare and keep them in check. They highlight the need for regulation to prevent overpricing.
SYNC Tests and litigation-based medicine: The article mentions "SYNC Tests" and explains that it's not possible to provide an in-depth explanation within their comment. They recommend reading about litigation-based medicine, providing a reference to an article on the topic.
Overall Sentiment:
Discontent with high charges and overpricing: Many messages express frustration and disappointment with the exorbitant prices charged by private hospitals for treatments, medications, and procedures. This sentiment is often accompanied by a sense of exploitation and unfairness.
Lack of trust in the healthcare system: Several messages highlight a lack of trust in private hospitals and their motives. There is a perception that hospitals prioritize profits over patient care and that doctors are influenced or controlled by the hospital management.
Support for transparency and accountability: Many messages express a desire for greater transparency in hospital pricing and billing practices. There is a call for regulatory measures and accountability for hospitals engaging in unethical practices.
Recognition of the plight of the poor: Some messages acknowledge the difficulties faced by economically disadvantaged individuals who are unable to afford expensive treatments and medications. There is a sense of empathy and concern for the marginalized sections of society.
Tag: Healthcare, Private hospitals, Medical costs, Overcharging, Unfair pricing, Patient care, Health insurance,Competition Commission of India, Affordable healthcare, Doctor-patient relationship, Healthcare affordability crisis,Alternative healthcare options, Ethical standards, Transparency in billing, Patient advocacy
Ref Links
Declaration:
Some comments are collected from YouTube based on this topic to understand the real-time sentiment of the public, patients, and caregivers. These comments reflect the opinions and experiences of individuals and do not represent professional advice or endorse any particular viewpoint. The purpose of including these comments is to provide a glimpse into the diverse range of perspectives on the subject matter and to enhance public awareness and understanding.
What did you think of this article?
We value your feedback and would love to hear your thoughts on this article.
Write to: hello at watchdoq dot com with questions or comments.
Additional Resources